jump to navigation

Top Friends still missing after 5 days; marks change in Facebook’s approach to app developers July 1, 2008

Posted by jeremyliew in apps, facebook.

Inside Facebook has an interesting post about Facebook’s evolving approach to platform management. Justin notes that Slide’s Top Friends app has now been suspended for the platform for 5 days, the most serious punishment for any app so far. He notes that while initially Facebook tried to control app developer behavior with rules, it is now singling out ‘bad actors’ for direct punishment, as much to be a symbol to other developers as to punish the infringing app.

Earlier in the year, Facebook responded to abuse by outlawing the tool being abused (for example, in the case of forced invites). This would be akin to outlawing something like assault rifles that almost everyone agrees are harmful to society. However, in more complex cases, outlawing the tool at hand is not necessarily what’s best for the system. For example, removing APIs that access profile data from the Platform altogether because of one application’s privacy concerns would hurt the overall Platform economy significantly: many developers and users would be negatively impacted. This would be somewhat like outlawing kitchen knives because they were once used in a crime. Instead of removing knives from society, the better solution would be to hire a district attorney and set up a court system and bill of rights: news of verdicts and sentences would deter many future cases. Of course, that’s a very expensive proposition, and sufficient accountability must be enforced for stakeholders to have faith in the system.

As he summarizes:

Facebook’s approach to platform governance is becoming decreasingly dependent on algorithms and increasingly based on policy-enforcement.

This is the same approach that Myspace has followed since inception. This change in approach is an important sea change for app developers as it makes direct relationships with Facebook more important than previously. This will likely benefit the larger app developers over the smaller ones so ong as they are acting in a way that Facebook likes.


1. aka Assault - July 16, 2008

“…..This would be akin to outlawing something like assault rifles that almost everyone agrees are harmful to society….”

Come now, where is the statistical survey proof of your bald assertion? The fact is (and with the same degree of “proof” as your statement) is that “almost everyone” does not agree that “assault rifles” are harmful to society. What new PC terms are we going to see next – “assault peanut butter knives, “assault cars”, how about “assault intoxicants”, or “assault(ed) peanuts? Sheesh leave the PC maudlin tear jerkers for the other blogs. OK so it is your blog and you can post what ever you want but, I was assaulted and distracted from the content of the thought that i guess your were trying to make.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: